Exit Sign Type Picker

Exit Sign Type Picker + ROI Calculator (LED vs Photoluminescent vs Tritium)

This resource helps facility managers pick the right exit sign technology—LED, Photoluminescent, or Tritium—and quantify ROI for new installs and retrofits. Written in plain English for Facilities and EHS teams. — Quick links: Exit Signs · Self-Luminous Exit Signs · Photoluminescent Exit Signs

Last updated: September 2025

Educational Guide UL 924 • NFPA 101 • OSHA Written for Facilities & EHS

 Quick Picks

LED — Default for Powered Areas

  • Bright, code-ready internal illumination; easy 100‑ft visibility.
  • Low energy (≈1–5 W), but requires wiring and battery testing.
  • Best where power exists and monthly/annual testing is routine.

Photoluminescent — Zero Power

  • No wiring, no batteries; charges from ambient light.
  • Needs consistent illumination during occupancy to meet code.
  • Best for retrofits, stairwells, and low-maintenance programs.

Tritium — No Power in Dark Areas

  • Self‑luminous; works without power or charging light.
  • Regulated end‑of‑life recycling; higher upfront cost.
  • Best for remote, dark, or hazardous locations.

Interactive Exit Sign ROI Calculator

Model 10–20 year total cost of ownership for LED, Photoluminescent, and Tritium exit signs using your real rates and labor. Results drive an on-page recommendation and portfolio savings.

Exit Sign Type Picker + ROI (LED vs Photoluminescent vs Tritium)

For Building Managers • Embeddable

Portfolio & Energy

LED Exit Sign — Costs

Optional labor: monthly testing minutes per sign × hourly rate.

Photoluminescent & Tritium — Costs

Site Constraints & Assumptions

Adjust defaults to match your facility. Values are placeholders – use your quotes/specs for precise results.

Recommendation

Ready when you are
Enter or confirm your inputs, then hit Calculate.

Lowest TCO (per sign)

Portfolio TCO

Payback vs LED

Photoluminescent

Annual Energy Saved

vs LED (portfolio)

Detailed Cost Comparison

Type Initial (per sign) Energy (period) Maintenance (period) Replacements & Disposal TCO (per sign) TCO (portfolio)
Payback is computed against LED by simulating year‑by‑year cumulative cost. If no crossover within the analysis window, “No payback” is shown.

This tool is for planning estimates only and does not replace local code review. Always use UL 924‑listed products and follow the AHJ’s guidance.

Exit Sign Types 101 (Facts)

LED (Electric, Battery‑Backed)

LED exit signs use light‑emitting diodes to provide continuous, internally illuminated “EXIT” lettering. They are hardwired (typically 120/277 VAC) and include a 90‑minute battery for outages. Modern units draw only a few watts and are the most common choice in powered buildings.

Photoluminescent (Non‑Electrical)

Photoluminescent signs charge from ambient light and glow in darkness—no wiring or batteries. To meet UL 924 and life‑safety codes, the sign face must receive sufficient light while occupied so it can remain visible for at least 90 minutes during a power loss.

Tritium (Self‑Luminous)

Tritium signs glow continuously via sealed gas tubes; they require no power or charging light. They have a rated life (10–20 years) and must be recycled at end‑of‑life as regulated devices.

Where Each Type Fits Best

  • LED: Most interiors with available power; high visibility; theater/assembly spaces with dimmed house lights.
  • Photoluminescent: Stairwells, corridors, schools, hospitals—areas lit during occupancy; historic retrofits with limited wiring.
  • Tritium: Remote/dark sites, utility rooms, hazardous or explosive atmospheres, locations where wiring or constant light is impractical.

Regulations & Compliance Snapshot (U.S.)

  • UL 924: Listing required for internally illuminated and self‑luminous signs; 90‑minute emergency performance.
  • NFPA 101 / IBC: Visibility, placement, letter size; continuous illumination during occupancy.
  • OSHA: Exit routes/signs must be readily visible and illuminated.
  • Tritium: Generally licensed device; recycle only at end‑of‑life via licensed recipients.
Always confirm details with your local Authority Having Jurisdiction (AHJ).

Why the Right Choice Matters (Safety, Cost, ESG)

  • Safety margin: Choose tech that remains visible in your actual lighting and power conditions.
  • Lifecycle cost: Wiring, battery testing, energy, and end‑of‑life fees drive total cost—not just purchase price.
  • ESG: Photoluminescent and tritium eliminate energy use; photolum avoids regulated waste.

How to Choose (Step‑by‑Step)

  1. Power availability: If power is readily available, LED is a strong default. If not, consider photolum or tritium.
  2. Ambient lighting: If the area is consistently lit during occupancy (≈5 fc at sign), photolum is viable. If not, avoid photolum.
  3. Use pattern: Spaces intentionally dark during use (auditoriums) → LED; normally unlit rooms → tritium.
  4. Environment: Hazardous/explosive atmospheres → tritium (or explosion‑proof LED).
  5. Maintenance capacity: Limited staff → favor photolum (lit areas) or tritium (dark/no‑power).
  6. Budget & ROI: Use the calculator to compare 10–20 year lifecycle costs across options.
Rule of thumb: No power & dark → Tritium, Power → LED, No power but well‑lit → Photolum.

Environmental & Sustainability Considerations

  • LED: Very low energy; batteries require proper disposal; periodic testing adds labor.
  • Photoluminescent: Zero energy and no hazardous components; relies on consistent ambient lighting.
  • Tritium: Zero energy; regulated end‑of‑life recycling; excellent for sites without power or light.

Comparison Table (Cost, Lifespan, Maintenance)

Best case Watch‑outs Not ideal
Feature LED Photoluminescent Tritium
Power source 120/277 VAC + battery Ambient light charged Self‑powered (H‑3 gas)
Lifespan Fixture 10–15 yrs; battery ≈4–5 yrs 20+ yrs if routinely charged 10–20 yrs (dims with half‑life)
Maintenance Monthly/annual tests; battery swaps Verify charging light; occasional cleaning None during life; track expiration; recycle
Upfront install Wiring required No wiring No wiring
Operating energy Low but non‑zero None None
Watch‑outs Battery neglect risk Needs reliable ambient light Regulated disposal; higher upfront

Deployment & Program Setup

  • Asset tracking: IDs, locations, type, install dates, service notes, (for tritium) expiration dates.
  • Testing plan: LED monthly/annual tests; document results. Photolum: periodic glow checks; confirm lighting.
  • Vendor management: Verify listings; maintain spec sheets and instructions; line up recycling partners if using tritium.
  • Continuous improvement: Reassess mix (LED/PL/Tritium) as building use or staffing changes.

Myths vs. Facts

  • “Photolum works anywhere.” — Only if the sign face is reliably illuminated during occupancy.
  • “LED always costs less.” — Upfront, often yes; lifecycle costs depend on testing labor and energy.
  • “Tritium is unsafe.” — Intact signs pose negligible external exposure; stewardship and recycling are the keys.
  • “Green letters are illegal.” — Many jurisdictions allow red or green; check local preferences.

Industry‑Specific Guidance

Healthcare & Labs

Favor photolum for low maintenance in lit corridors; coordinate with RSO if selecting tritium; document testing/inspections.

Hospitality & Retail

LED for guest‑facing aesthetics (edge‑lit); photolum in back‑of‑house; ensure dimmed areas use internally lit signs.

Transit & Tunnels

Manage vibration and moisture; mix photolum (path marking) with LED or tritium where power/lighting is unreliable.

Schools & Universities

Photolum reduces maintenance workload; schedule upgrades during breaks; use LED in assembly spaces with dimming.

Remote/Industrial Sites

Truly dark/no‑power areas → tritium; hazardous atmospheres → tritium or explosion‑proof LED; document expiration cycles.

Further Reading

Checklists & Templates (Downloads)

ROI Calculator (XLSX)

Compare 10–20 year lifecycle costs for LED, Photoluminescent, and Tritium based on your inputs.

Download ROI Calculator

Decision Checklist (CSV)

Yes/No prompts that map directly to the decision steps—great for walkthroughs and AHJ discussions.

Download Checklist

Visuals & Explainers (Placeholders)

Diagram showing LED (wired), Photoluminescent (charged by light), and Tritium (self‑luminous) exit sign concepts.
Three technologies, three power models—choose based on power, lighting, and maintenance realities.
Comparison table visual placeholder
[Table] Side‑by‑side comparison of power, lifespan, maintenance, and watch‑outs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I mix technologies in one building?

Yes—many facilities use LED in most areas, photolum in stairwells, and tritium in hard‑to‑serve or dark spaces.

What letter color should I choose?

Follow local preferences (often red or green allowed). Green is very legible for photolum/tritium; LED supports both.

How do I estimate maintenance labor?

Include monthly/annual LED tests and battery swaps. Photolum requires minimal checks; tritium needs expiration tracking.

Do photolum signs really work after hours?

Yes, if they’re consistently charged during occupancy; they glow long enough for required egress duration.

Are tritium signs difficult to manage?

No day‑to‑day work; just plan recycling at end‑of‑life and keep simple inventory/expiration records.

Tools & Calls‑to‑Action

Run Your Numbers

Open the ROI spreadsheet, set quantity, rates, and assumptions, then compare options over 10–20 years.

Spec & AHJ Packet

Bundle UL listings, photometrics, and decision checklist for a smooth plan review.

Talk to a Specialist

Need help validating assumptions or deployment plan? Use the checklist and call your vendor rep.